Ashaji not a good judge of talent: Darbar on music legend
Surat, June 7: Reputed music director Ismail Darbar was in the city to promote a singing talent hunt show televised by a national channel where he presides over as one of the judges. The city which also happens to be his birthplace and home for 15 years of his childhood will soon see a professional music school come to life and Darbar says the project is underway and will be completed soon.
Vociferous about his disapproval of Asha Bhosle as a co-judge on the show Ismail says, “Asha has made many mistakes while judging talent in the competition.
She is not a good judge and rejected quite a few people with talent.”
Arguing that music directors make better judges than singers in choosing talented singers Ismails says, “A music director has a good knowledge of sur and taal and he can guide the singer while composing a song but a singer may not always be competent enough to do the same.”
(source: rediff.com)
July 10th, 2007 at 1:34 pm
what the …. is Ismail talking about/ The men is crazy. Asha Bhosle is the best. How can he say such stupit thing. He will never achieve what Asha have. He is nothing comparing to asha. Asha is the boss. The best vocalist ever. And talking about music. Please do remember the album Aap Ki Asha in wich she had composed so lovely in beautifull song in different styles, from classical, to african latin american etc. She is singing almost 60 years= how can Ismail say that she has no knowlegde. AAAAAAAAAAAAAh stupid Ismail.
Asha Bhosle is the best judge.
July 20th, 2007 at 3:01 pm
Dear radjesh…
i find no point to be so irritate upon the words of Darbar. everyone has aight to explicit his/her views, so far Darbar words are concerned it is really absurd…
A verdict of Asha ji is much more important than the opinions of 50,000 music listeners and television shows viewers …. her judgement should be regarded as the last word
BUT
what do u say when a legend like Asha ji intends to sing with a non singer – Sachin tendulker??
do u think it is a good decission??
and leave the judgement of the mastereos , what would u judge when it comes to a comparison of her own rendered songs with Rafi sb and Kishore…..
She is also a human being … may be she has missed something in her judgement and may be darbar got much excited to put a word on her judgement.
BUT REMEBER ONE FACT
BEAUTY AND TALENT ARE NEVER A SLAVE AND PROPERTY OF A PARTICULAR PERSON. ASHA JI AND DARBAR ….. BOTH ARE GREAT AS PER THEIR TALENTS AND PERFORMANCES.
August 7th, 2007 at 6:35 am
What Radjesh had to say about Darbar comments on the ONE and ONLY and THE Living Legend, and Diva, is bang on! Asha Bhosle’s name alone speaks for itself. Simboo.
September 29th, 2007 at 10:39 pm
Glamour Modeling Agency…
hey great stuff…